Recentering Substantive Fairness in Antidiscrimination Law

Recentering Substantive Fairness in Antidiscrimination Law

The current attack on DEI in workplaces is, at bottom, an attack on a substantive vision of “fairness” in work. It is an attack on employment practices, the way that employers treat their workers. To the extent that employers—in the wake of protests after the murder of George Floyd or otherwise—had undertaken antidiscrimination measures aimed at structural change, seeking to assess and modify their own institutional practices to increase diversity, equity, and inclusion for all of their workers, the Trump Administration has demanded that those institutions self-assess and “undo” their efforts, turning the handle back by returning to their practices of the past. Yet long before DEI became a racialized corporate buzzword (made so primarily by those presenting the attacks), institutional practices of racial inclusion have been authorized as part of antidiscrimination law’s concern with fairness. Indeed, the attack on DEI is part of a broader movement to undermine Title VII as a tool for institutional assessment and change. Simultaneously with the attack on DEI, the Trump Administration has continued an ongoing assault on the substantive fundamental fairness components of Title VII law—the disparate impact method of proof, use of class actions and broad injunctive relief, voluntary affirmative action, and any recognition of subordination of groups in the United States, among others. Most perniciously, the attack is based on a shift in thinking about discrimination in employment that narrows basic fairness away from employer practices as context and structure for decisions and instead centers the inquiry on processes for HR decisions and bias or animus in individual mindsets.

In this Article, we document the overarching assault on antidiscrimination law as a decentering of a substantive vision of fairness in work and, in the spirit of the call of this Symposium, we look toward setting the foundation for a stronger future for employment discrimination law in a multiracial democracy. Recentering substantive fairness in employment discrimination law, we argue, must be a matter of shifting our thinking for all claims away from isolated HR decisional processes and mindsets and toward employment practices. We identify three conceptual cruxes for recentering substantive fairness in our thinking—resisting a narrowing of the lens of time, resisting a narrowing of the lens of space, and breaking across boundaries—and we consider ways for prioritizing these conceptual cruxes concretely in Title VII, now and in the future.

#