Federal Courts and the Exceptional South: Boundary Control and Multiracial Democracy

Federal Courts and the Exceptional South: Boundary Control and Multiracial Democracy

The federal courts’ confrontation with a belligerent South defines much of the relationship between federal courts and the advancement of multiracial democracy. From the Reconstruction era to the present day, depictions of the federal courts as either a progressive or regressive force in American law and politics have been based on their treatment of retrograde Southern states or policies associated with Jim Crow authoritarianism. In short, the level of deference federal courts afford Southern state governments substantially shapes their reputation regarding race. That the South figures so prominently in an evaluation of federal courts is unsurprising given the region’s centrality in the defining confrontations over national power to protect the rights of racial minorities. This Essay explores the role that sectionalism—here understood as a form of sectional isolation or Southern exceptionalism—has played in justifying and limiting the scope of national judicial authority. It does so by analyzing the role that federal courts play in the boundary control of subnational authoritarian regimes.

#