Over a few months in 2025, the second Trump Administration dismantled the infrastructure for federal civil rights enforcement in the United States. In this Article, we describe key elements of this assault, assess its impact, and sketch the beginnings of a set of longer-term goals for remaking civil rights enforcement.
We begin with the premise that there is no returning to the same doctrinal and institutional structures set up in the second part of the twentieth century. Restoring the regime to provide the protections that existed on January 20, 2025, would resurrect what was already a hollowed-out system that fell far short of the aspirations that first propelled it. Nor do we advise restoring the regime to the contours it occupied in 1970, for example, before the many cutbacks that prevented it from operating as intended. Such a restoration simply would not be feasible, even if the political will existed to implement the far more modest legal changes we recommend here. Nor would such a restoration directly address the evolution in both the manifestation of discriminatory practices and the resistance to remedies for them.
We must instead rethink both the substantive doctrines through which we seek to achieve democratic equality and the institutional structures through which those doctrines will be elaborated and enforced. Examining the events of the last year, we believe that a lasting infrastructure for civil rights enforcement requires direct engagement with the specific tactics the current Administration has used to dismantle the pre-existing system. This Article focuses on three of these tactics, which we label erasure, demolition, and weaponization. More specifically, it argues that rebuilding will require structures designed to withstand future efforts that seek to: (1) erase existing data pertaining to race, ethnicity, and gender in a host of realms and terminate the further collection and reporting of such data by both public and private entities; (2) demolish federal civil rights offices within various agencies that worked to promote multiracial democracy; and (3) weaponize the longstanding enforcement tools of civil rights law against the goals of multiracial equality and democracy. This Article sketches some preliminary proposals for doing so.
These proposals vary. Some require significant but ultimately straightforward legislative action. For instance, Congress should codify the data collection and reporting requirements canceled by the Trump Administration, eliminate funding cancellation as an enforcement tool, and explicitly provide for a private right to enforce foundational civil rights laws. Others are more complex. We envision new or significantly restructured agencies and institutions designed to block assaults of the sort that occurred in the past year. To build such institutions would require both legislative and judicial changes that seem unlikely in the near term. Together, these
proposals rest on the assumption that rebuilding the federal civil rights infrastructure in any meaningful way will require a dramatic change in political will sufficient in scale both to usher into office enough legislators willing and able to enact the proposed measures, as well as to secure the appointment of enough federal judges inclined to uphold them. Achieving this vision will require sustained effort over the long term.