Spaces for Opportunity: Animating the Right to Education in the Reconstruction of Democracy

Spaces for Opportunity: Animating the Right to Education in the Reconstruction of Democracy

In the first months of the second Trump Administration, a series of executive orders and administrative decisions implemented an abrupt and dramatic change in the direction of federal educational policy. As the Trump administration sought to eliminate all federal grants, funding, and guidance that appeared to advance goals of racial justice, educators absorbed the devastating effects. Prior to these seismic executive shifts, however, the nation has perpetually grappled with reaching true educational equality. Rather than attempting to find ways to address the most recent national reckoning, this article seeks to contextualize these current seismic shifts amidst the deeper landscape of congressional, executive, and jurisprudential efforts to reach true educational literacy within the United States’s fraught racial history. In doing so, one may use these historic lessons to chart a more hopeful path for the future. This article looks beyond the existing damage to examine spaces for opportunity in articulating, animating, and advancing unrealized rights to education as a cornerstone of a racially inclusive democracy. As a rise in nativism and the specter of authoritarianism loom large, this watershed moment calls for a renewed commitment to education in the form of racial and historical literacy that are foundational to true multiracial democracy.

This article therefore proceeds in three parts. Part I provides insight into the current crisis in education caused by recent federal executive actions, including those by the United States Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights. These actions both weaponize the language used by government entities and decimate long-standing educational infrastructure. The result of such actions allows for the creation and dissemination of a false narrative regarding our nation’s racial history and the need for true educational literacy for a healthy multiracial democracy. Part II examines the role of education in framing constitutional rights and responsibilities to highlight both the deep-seated constitutional commitment to racial literacy as a means to true democracy, and to highlight the perpetual failure to reach this commitment over time. This contrast of past and present exposes what theorist Gloria Ladsen Billings astutely labels an “education debt” which we believe must be paid to future generations through racial and historical literacy. Finally, in Part III, we envision potential paths to a constitutional future where rights to education and literacy are centered and realized in policy. These measures would both enhance the rights of educators and the self-determination of learners in schools. We build on existing models from international examples like Finland and South Africa, as well as local measures like Montana’s State Constitution. We see a future where children are not only foundational to democratic education, but participants and framers of rights held and exercised by all.

#