American citizenship is often imagined as the legal embodiment of democratic progress—an ever-widening circle of inclusion oriented toward equality. That account misdescribes how citizenship has functioned in the United States. The history of citizenship in the United States is not simply one of expansion, but of patterned reversal: moments of inclusion have repeatedly generated new modes of exclusion.
Race has been central to this dynamic. The racialization of citizenship has done more than mark the boundary between members and nonmembers; it has also accommodated both reforms and retrenchments.
From the nation’s founding through Reconstruction and into the present, law has functioned simultaneously as a gateway to membership and as an instrument for producing and managing racial boundaries. Citizenship-enhancing reforms, such as the Fourteenth Amendment, have routinely been followed by interpretive, doctrinal, and institutional maneuvers that narrow their reach, from the constitutionalization of separate-but-equal to contemporary efforts to weaken the modern civil-rights infrastructure. Citizenship has operated as both a closed door that restricts membership and as an open one that grants it on hierarchical terms.
This introductory Article situates current challenges to birthright citizenship, affirmative action, voting rights, and civil rights enforcement within that longer arc, tracing how cycles of reform and retrenchment have structured the architecture of American citizenship. Its central claim is that today’s ethnonationalist turn is not a deviation from an otherwise linear civil rights trajectory, but the most recent iteration
of a recurring pattern.
Recognizing this dynamic does not require resignation. Nor does it license easy optimism. Because retrenchments are forged at the interstices of resistance and repression, they are neither complete nor conclusive social arrangements. They are unstable sites of contestation with the generative capacity to expose fragility, clarify unfinished work, and produce forms of citizenship more expansive, more resilient, and more transformative than earlier iterations.